Best New American Restaurant in Old Town, Fort Collins

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Fort Collins, CO at 104 W Olive St

Fort Collins' table since 2004

Order online

Featured

View menu

We're Nominated For Best Burger!

Best Burger in NOCO Style's Best of Awards!

Try for yourself!

The Buffalo Reuben

Find them alongside lunch, dinner, sips, and sweets at Choice City.

See our menu

From Our Choice City Family

A neighborhood place, still going strong

Choice City began as a butcher-to-deli and grew into a full-service lunch and dinner spot next to The Armstrong Hotel.

Our story

10/10 food. 10/10 atmosphere. 10/10 service. I had the Truffle Grove Burger, Tamarind Carrots on the side, and Maple Spice Cake for dessert. The cocktail is Orchard Affair. A fall cocktail - incredibly delicious. Everything was perfect, including the service. Warm, welcoming, comforting atmosphere.

Elle

Exceptional food, exceptional service, exceptional atmosphere. Thank you guys so much for making my birthday EXTRA special! Everyone at the table was blown away by the hospitality and the food. The lemon herb chicken with broccolini was exquisite. We got to try some mocktails and they were all SO tasty. Our favorite part was the dessert - the maple pumpkin spice cake…OMG!!! So delicious. Thank you guys so much!!! I can’t wait to come back.

lily I.

Absolutely phenomenal. Lavi and her team will make your experience one you will never forget. From the delicious hand-crafted cocktails/mocktails to the best burgers (including the amazing “best damn VEG” burger!!) in town, you will leave Choice City already thinking about when you can go back! Avery was our server and truly, no notes. This girl rocked it, and we had exceptional service!

Bridget E.

I try a different sandwich every time I come here. My favorite is the spicy Italian. But everything I try is delicious. It feels like every sandwich was thought out and has a purpose. I highly recommend.

J D.

Choice City Rewards

Join our rewards program, earn points every time you order online and redeem your points for free food!

Join now

The dining room and bar

The 2025 refresh brought a new look to the room. Settle in for dinner and cocktails in Old Town.

Make a reservation

Frequently Asked Questions

What are you known for?

We are known for Sandwiches, Deli Sandwiches, Grilled Cheese, Burgers, Grilled Chicken, Short Rib, Chicken Tenders, Fries, Blt, Cheesesteak, Bar Food, Patty Melt, and Fusion Restaurant

What meals do you serve?

We serve Lunch and Dinner

Do you offer delivery or takeout?

Yes, we offer Takeout and Delivery

Where are you located?

We are located in Fort Collins, CO at 104 W Olive St

What areas do you serve?

We serve the following areas: Fort Collins, Andersonville, Drakes, Arrowhead, Omega, McClellands, Sinnard, Giddings, Harmony, Laporte, Boettcher, Bellvue, Horsetooth Heights, Timnath, Kluver, Redmond, Wellington, Kerns, Masonville, and Waverly.